How Level 3 and 4 Mark the Turning Point Where Understanding Becomes Inner Vision
We often mistake ritual observance and emotional stirring as ends in themselves. In reality, they are diagnostic tools, not destinations. They indicate the state of our inner development—the level at which the self is currently operating. True growth is a spiral ascension, a movement that begins horizontally and gradually rises: from habitual actions → emotional awakening → reflective heart → awakened soul → nourished intellect.
By grounding this model in Level 3: The Emotional Seeker – Heart Awakening (link) and Level 4: The Reflective Heart – Emerging Sincerity (link), we can see how Islam’s practices are designed to activate, elevate, and integrate the self—spiritually, emotionally, and cognitively.
Level 3 of the Soul: Understanding Without Expression
At Level 3, the mind may grasp complex concepts, and the heart may respond, but the soul remains dormant. Comprehension is internal, but integration is absent. This is why understanding is often misconstrued as spirituality: the mind and heart can be aware, yet the vertical plane of the soul has not been activated.
I have encountered this many times: explaining a deep concept, people seem to understand it as if it were ordinary logic. They may say, “Yes, that is logical,” yet they have not generated the insight themselves. Pride is a flaw that blocks the integration of understanding into the soul and prevents the spiral from ascending.
Without deliberate cultivation, the student often loses the entire program: insights evaporate, habits fail, emotional responsiveness flattens. The knowledge remains horizontal, the heart partially engaged, and the mind alone cannot sustain the program.
The Teacher’s Role and Recognition
A skilled teacher does more than convey information; they awaken insight and prepare the soul for ascension. They can discern the state of the student by observing responses:
-
Repetition without integration?
-
Nodding but inability to articulate or apply the concept?
-
Subtle signs of pride, defensiveness, or detachment?
These responses reveal whether the mind, heart, or soul is dominant—or absent. Recognizing these patterns allows the teacher to guide reflection, correct flaws, and prevent collapse, ensuring that the spiral begins its upward trajectory.
Level 4 – Reflective Heart: Spiritual Incline
Level 4 represents the first vertical turn of the spiral. The heart begins to respond to the soul, creating an incline toward higher planes.
-
The soul, as the most fundamental plane of the self, awakens and pulls the heart upward.
-
Sincerity emerges: rituals are no longer performed purely by habit, and emotional responses are tempered by awareness.
-
Reflection deepens: tafsir, contemplation, and self-examination guide the heart and actions.
-
System 2 begins to engage: deliberate attention, critical reflection, and conscious choice emerge as regular practice.
At this stage, what was once horizontal (habitual, emotionally reactive) starts rising, and even System 1 is refined. The automatic self begins to act in alignment with heart and soul, forming a spiralic ascension.
System 1 and System 2 in the Islamic Paradigm
Kahneman’s Thinking, Fast and Slow illustrates:
-
System 1 → automatic self: fast, intuitive, habitual.
-
System 2 → reflective intellect: deliberate, effortful, capable of overriding default responses.
Islam’s framework maps directly onto these systems:
-
System 1 governs ritual habits and emotional responses.
-
System 2 is engaged through tafsir, reflection, and study.
Through regular spiritual and intellectual practice, System 1 gradually aligns with the higher plane, integrating habit, emotion, and intention.
Spiral Ascension: From Horizontal to Vertical
-
Level 3 (Horizontal): Ritual and emotion dominate; understanding is internal; pride or lack of cultivation risks collapse.
-
Level 4 (Incline): Reflective heart; soul awakens and pulls heart upward; System 2 shapes System 1.
-
Later Levels (Vertical): Mind is fed through tafsir, study, and reflection; the automatic self now acts in harmony with the soul; insight is expressed and lived.
The spiral illustrates holistic growth: heart, soul, and mind ascend together, elevating the self beyond routine knowledge into conscious, living wisdom.
Practical Implications
-
Identify your level: internal comprehension without integration = Level 3; reflective heart aligning with soul = Level 4.
-
Deepen reflective practices: tafsir, dhikr, self-examination, honest contemplation.
-
Use rituals diagnostically: detect gaps in heart or soul integration.
-
Feed the mind: reading, reasoning, analysis, and structured study elevate System 2, retraining System 1.
-
Cultivate humility: pride blocks integration and can cause collapse of understanding.
-
Teachers should observe responses carefully to guide students effectively, preventing loss of insight.
Through this integrated approach, the entire self ascends, spiraling upward into higher levels of sincerity, reflection, and wisdom.
Comments
Post a Comment